Skip to content
Dimensional vs. Vanguard
Dimensional vs. Vanguard: which is better for an expat investor, and does the choice matter as much as you think?
9:22


When people find out I work in finance, the first question is usually about their pension or the markets.

The second question is the one I hear more than any other. It rarely comes from the families I've known for years. It comes from people who've started investing on their own, read the books and built a sensible portfolio.

So, Dimensional vs Vanguard: which is better?

I'll give you the short answer first, then the detail. Before the detail, the points that matter most:

  • Both Dimensional and Vanguard are sound choices. Either one is likely to serve you better than high-charging structured products, cash left in the bank for years, or a portfolio of expensive active funds.
  • Vanguard mainly builds low-cost index funds that hold a market in proportion to its size. Dimensional builds systematic funds that hold more of smaller and lower-priced companies, because research suggests those have offered higher expected returns over long periods.
  • Dimensional funds cost more. Its first two European UCITS ETFs, listed in November 2025, charge 0.26% and 0.44% a year. Vanguard's broad index funds typically charge less, and its single-market index funds far less.
  • Dimensional's tilt has had long, painful stretches of lagging the market, most recently when large US growth companies led for much of the 2010s. Anyone choosing it needs to be able to sit through those years.
  • The fund house matters less than your behaviour. In Morningstar's 2026 study, investors earned about 1.2 percentage points a year less than the funds they held, largely through badly timed buying and selling.

How Vanguard and Dimensional build portfolios

The two firms share more history than you'd expect. Both grew out of academic work on markets in the 1960s and 1970s. Both believe that trying to pick winning stocks is a losing game for most investors.

Where they part company is in what to hold instead.

What is Vanguard?

Vanguard is the firm that brought index investing to ordinary investors. John Bogle founded it in 1975, and in 1976 it launched the first index mutual fund for individual investors in the US.

An index fund holds every company in a market index, weighted by size. Its aim is to match the market's return, minus a very small cost.

Vanguard now offers 227 funds in the US and 231 in markets outside the US, and manages around $12 trillion, according to Vanguard's own figures. Its funds and ETFs are easy to buy on most investment platforms, which is why it has become the default for do-it-yourself investors.

What is Dimensional?

Dimensional Fund Advisors is a systematic fund manager founded in 1981 by David Booth and Rex Sinquefield. Its approach draws heavily on the research of Eugene Fama and Kenneth French on what drives differences in returns between stocks.

Dimensional's funds look like index funds in many ways. They're broadly diversified, low turnover and rules-based. The difference is that Dimensional sets its own rules for what to hold and how much of it. It also trades with more flexibility than a fund tied to an index's rebalancing dates.

That's why the question often appears online as DFA vs Vanguard: DFA is the shorthand for Dimensional Fund Advisors.

What does it mean to tilt a portfolio?

Tilting a portfolio means holding more of certain types of company than the market does.

Dimensional tilts towards three characteristics:

  • Size: smaller companies.
  • Value: companies with low prices relative to measures such as book value.
  • Profitability: companies with higher profits relative to their size.

This approach is often called factor investing. Decades of research suggest these characteristics have been linked to higher returns over long periods. The research also shows those higher returns come with periods, sometimes long ones, when they don't show up at all. Some researchers argue that discomfort is the reason the extra return exists in the first place.

Dimensional vs Vanguard: how they compare

The table below sets out the practical differences for an investor living outside the US.

  Vanguard Dimensional
Approach Index funds weighted by company size  Systematic funds tilted to size, value and profitability 
Aim Match the market at the lowest cost Capture higher expected returns over long periods 
Typical cost of a global equity fund  Around 0.2% a year or less [verify: current OCF of Vanguard FTSE All-World UCITS ETF]  0.26% to 0.44% a year for its European UCITS ETFs 
How you buy Directly, on most platforms Mostly through advisers and institutions 
Range  231 funds outside the US  Smaller range, now including UCITS ETFs 
Main risk relative to the market  Very little: you get the market   Long stretches of lagging the market 
Ownership US firm owned by its US-domiciled funds  Private firm 

How much do Dimensional and Vanguard funds cost?

Vanguard funds are among the cheapest available. In the US, Vanguard's average asset-weighted expense ratio was 0.06% at the end of 2025, against an industry average of 0.39%, according to Vanguard.

Dimensional funds cost more because they do more. Its first active UCITS ETFs, listed in London and Frankfurt in November 2025, charge 0.26% a year for Global Core Equity and 0.44% for Global Targeted Value.

A difference of 0.2% to 0.4% a year sounds small. Over twenty or thirty years it compounds into real money, so the tilt has to earn its extra cost over time.

Can you buy Dimensional funds without an adviser?

Buying Dimensional funds without an adviser is usually difficult. Dimensional has always sold mainly through financial advisers and institutions, and its European ETF announcement says the same.

Vanguard's ownership model mostly stays in the US

Vanguard's ownership structure only partly applies to expats. Vanguard is often described as owned by its investors, and in the US that's true. The Vanguard Group is owned by its US-domiciled funds and ETFs, which are owned by their investors.

Most expats hold Vanguard's Irish-domiciled UCITS funds instead. Vanguard says its US ownership structure can't be replicated outside the US for regulatory reasons. You still benefit from the low costs that structure helps produce, but you don't own a slice of the firm.

What the evidence says, including the hard years

 

The short answer is, both are great, have strengths and weaknesses, and are better than what 99% of international investors are invested in.

If I could wave a wand and move all the trillions of dollars sat languishing in low-interest deposit accounts with banks, toxic structured products or poorly performing active funds portfolios - to either of these, I would.

Pick either one and you’ll likely have made a good choice.

However, there's a deeper explanation I'd like to get into, to better explain how they're individually set up to capture returns.

There may be some industry jargon along the way (which I usually try to avoid) but I promise to do my best to simplify it.

But first, a short intro. 

Dimensional Fund Advisers

For more than 30 years, Dimensional has been translating compelling research into practical investment solutions for their clients. This short video below explains the deep connections between academic finance and Dimensional’s approach to investing and how the firm’s focus on data and implementation, and its ability to adapt as research evolves, helps investors.

More information on why AES use DFA, can be found here. 

Vanguard

Vanguard’s founder, John Bogle, started the first retail index fund. The firm operates much like a non-profit. Technically, it’s a co-op. Every investor in Vanguard’s products owns of sliver of the business. The firm is also Mecca for do-it-yourself investors. But they have financial advisers, too. 

Dimensional or Vanguard: what are their fund's main differences?

The main differences between Vanguard and Dimensional Fund Advisors’ index funds are:

1. They use different indexes

2. They have different charging structures

3. They have a different approach to fund management

Vanguard has more than 60 unique funds to choose from and each fund tracks an index in a bond or stock market.

The firm is owned by its fund shareholders, meaning it’s essentially a non-profit.

As a result, the average Vanguard index fund expense ratio is very low (82% lower than the average mutual fund).

Dimensional (DFA) on the other hand, doesn’t simply track an index (lagging it by tracking error and the small cost), they custom design their funds to try and capture risk factors - such as company size and value - to maximise expected dimensions of return for their clients.

For an in-depth look into Dimensional, click here. 

They “tilt” their portfolios: this means they have an investment strategy that attempts to enjoy better fund returns by having a heavier weighting of certain stocks that have historically delivered higher returns than the stock market.

In the case of DFA, they tilt towards small-cap stocks and value stocks.

Small cap is a term used to classify companies with a relatively small market capitalisation - between $300 million and $2 billion.

A value stock is considered to be trading at a lower price relative to its fundamentals - like dividends, earnings and sales.

It is considered undervalued by a value investor.

DFA says they have other advantages over traditional index funds like Vanguard’s, too.

For example, when a new stock enters an index, a traditional index fund has to add it all at once, and this can push the price up before the purchase is completed.

But because DFA is working to characteristics not names, they build their portfolios differently.

In theory, this means they can avoid a cost bump that pure stock-list-following index funds can experience.

According to Andrew Hallam writing for Asset Builder:

“[DFA] also built [their funds] by the characteristics of each stock, rather than duplicating an index that roughly identified a characteristic.

These funds cost more than traditional index funds, but their back-tested studies said the cost would be worth it.”

Which brings me to my next point…

Dimensional or Vanguard: costs vs. returns

By actively weighting a portfolio to try and capture greater gains, DFA’s index funds require a slightly more systematic management which means investors pay more.

Such an active-passive approach is called ‘smart beta’ in the industry.

Andrew Hallam says:

“DFA’s funds have beaten the broad U.S. market. But that’s to be expected because DFA tilts its funds towards value and small cap stocks.

The S&P 500 gained a total of 122% from January 1, 1999 to December 31, 2015. U.S. value stocks gained 167%. U.S. small cap stocks gained 318%”.

Jared Kizer of Buckingham Wealth Partners compared Dimensional and Vanguard fund performance between October 1999 and June 2018 by crafting three equally weighted portfolios covering U.S. Equity, International Equity and Emerging Markets Equity.

Overall, the Dimensional Fund portfolios produced both higher compound returns and risk-adjusted returns compared to the Vanguard market-capitalisation-weighted portfolios over the years.

More specifically, the international and emerging market Dimensional Funds have performed more consistently compared to the U.S. funds.

However, there have been some time periods where the Vanguard portfolios outperformed the DFA portfolios.

Table: DFA vs Vanguard performance

Every DFA U.S. equity fund that existed when the new millennium began has since outgained the S&P 500.

That is a record unmatched by any rival fund company.

The research shows that for a long-term investment strategy, representative funds from Dimensional have outperformed on a relative basis against Vanguard.

In the table below, we compare a select group of popular Vanguard index mutual funds that track major asset classes. The chart shows the annual return of equivalent Dimensional and Vanguard funds from 2000 until March 2021.

Vanguard vs Dimensional annual returns graph


Across large value stocks, the difference in return is negligible. 

However, it's in the small-cap and value-focused funds that Dimensional excels.

Leading academics like Eugene Fama and Kenneth French (who are also on the Board of DFA) believe that favouring value stocks comes with higher expected returns over time.

As mentioned earlier, in nearly all asset classes, DFA is more heavily weighted to smaller-sized stocks (which historically outperform large caps over the long term) than Vanguard.

Dimensional's funds also favour value-style stocks, which have produced greater returns on average than growth-oriented stocks.

So what's the verdict?

Pick either Dimensional or Vanguard and you won’t go too far wrong.

As the picture below shows, most of the world are still invested in traditional active assets (in red) or worse .

Passive Index funds are better (in blue) as they lag the market by cost and tracking error.

Systematically or evidence-based portfolios represent a credible opportunity to capture higher expected returns (the green distribution) via tilts.

Return distribution chart

However, there is a far more critical factor that can make all the difference to your returns.

And that's who you choose as your lifetime financial partner.

According to IFA.com:

“Knowledgeable, evidence-based advisers help maximise investor success, because they provide the critical discipline needed to combat emotional, reflex reactions - like pulling out of the market the way so many did in late 2008, early 2009, or in 2011.

Evidence-based or systematic advisers not only help to manage an investor's emotions, they serve as fiduciary stewards of their clients' wealth.”

In other words, choose Vanguard, choose DFA, or choose a different ETF altogether - but choose to work with a chartered evidence-based fiduciary with a strong, documented investment philosophy if you want the returns that are right for you.

This is because:

  1. They help you stay invested by managing your emotions and behavioural biases
  2. They rebalance you through market turbulence
  3. They help choose the investments that are right for you and your life plan, not the latest fad.

So, the ultimate answer is: it depends on you, your personal circumstances, goals and financial situation.

The financial world can be murky, full of complexities and nuances that are difficult to navigate alone.

A professional, certified fiduciary is perhaps best suited to help those with a high degree of complexity, a limited amount of time, substantial capital and ambition to maximise not only their return on investments but also their return on life.

I'm here whenever you're ready.

Message us