About   Careers   Blog

Back to blog

Blog Feature
Sam Instone

By: Sam Instone

Print this Page

March 19th, 2019

To own, rent or hail (think Uber). That is the question. Time to keep your investing head; it's just another paradigm shift.

Financial Planning

As expats, we’re often torn between renting and owning.

Everything from cars to property.

I touched on the latter last week.

Today, let’s talk cars.

You’ve just moved to a new country

And decided to lease rather than purchase a car.

Seems sensible.

But now you’ve committed to a never-ending car payment.

You’ll go from rental to rental without ever owning.

Your car becomes another bill, like gas and electric…

But never a possession.

This is an expensive choice.

Here’s why.

Over the past 100 years, car ownership has skyrocketed.

This time, though, it will sharply decline.

Cars are already parked 95% of the time.

Parked car

Making them not only an underused asset…

But a depreciating one at that.

For many ‘savvy’ expats, the answer to this buy-or-rent conundrum is ‘on demand’ alternatives like Uber.

Booking a trip is a click away – and you pay by the minute or by the kilometre.

Quite literally a ‘pay as you go’ model.

No upfront costs, deposits, maintenance or repair bills, insurance or e-tolls.

You get a vehicle when you need it.

But this creates another paradigm shift.

With fewer people buying cars, the prices of used cars plummet.

Analysts predict a 50 percent decline in used car prices over the next few years.

Rent, buy or hail – what makes better financial sense?

According to stats provided by the Roads and Transport Authority, Dubai has 540 cars per 1,000 people.

It’s one of the highest in the world.

A piece in Gulf News, compares costs against buying, renting or hailing.

 

Buying:

The most commonly driven car in the UAE is the Toyota Corolla.

Take the 2018 model.

  • Total cost: AED 70,900
  • 20% down-payment: AED 14,180
  • Monthly payment: Around AED 980 over 5 years

Extra costs:

  • AED 3,000 – AED 4,000 for comprehensive insurance
  • AED 1,000 for registration and inspection fees
  • AED 1,000 for cleaning, service and maintenance costs
  • AED 4,000-AED 5,000 for tolls and fuel

Total yearly cost: AED 20,800 (excluding down-payment)

Pay

 

Renting:

(Using a basic Sedan as an example)

Monthly payment: AED 2,000 to AED 3,000

Extra costs: AED 4,000-5,000 in tolls and fuel

Total yearly cost: AED 40,500

 

Hailing:

(Assuming you hail a car or order a car for AED 40 to AED 50 one way – which is AED 100 a day, five days a week).

Monthly payment: AED 2,500

Extra costs: 0

Total yearly cost: AED 24,000

 

The verdict?

Owning a car may be the better choice.

It’s yours to own and re-sell, giving you money back in your pocket.

Renting or hailing pays the supplier or provider only.

You to never see that money (or even part of it) again.

When buying, remember new cars depreciate faster in the first year.

So used cars may be a better option.

But make sure it’s in good condition to avoid unanticipated, costly repairs.

Cars are emotional assets.

I could advise you for or against it, but it’s often a matter of personal circumstance.

A decision that’s part of a wider financial plan.

And may require an expert’s insight to steer you in the right direction.

Ask about our Index Account today

How do you pay to get from A to B?

Why not leave me a comment, I’d love to hear from you.

About Sam Instone

Sam Instone, Director at AES International, is passionate about positive change and ensuring international investors get better results.

  • Connect with Sam Instone