About   Careers   Blog
lea

Are active fund managers dying out? [video]

And what challenges are managers facing?

    Active fund managers are continuously struggling to beat their benchmarks...

    With this in mind, do active managers still add value?  

    Ben Johnson from Morningstar in Chicago, explains why it's so difficult for them to outperform...

    RP: It’s widely known — at least it is within the investing industry — that active fund managers have had a difficult few years. Even only relatively short time periods, they’re struggling to beat their benchmarks. So, is it getting harder for active managers to add value? And if so, why? Here’s Ben Johnson from Morningstar in Chicago.

    BJ: If you just think of the availability of information, the level of training just how many well-credentialed and equipped professionals are out there competing directly against one another for what is a finite and probably shrinking pool of alpha. This is a real challenge that is facing active managers, not just in the US but in all corners of the globe, and it is one that I do not think will soon reverse.

    RP: Some say there are other, specific reasons why outperformance has been so rare in recent years. Some managers, for instance, blame it on quantitative easing or on low interest rates.  But, says Ben Johnson, we should be wary of such excuses — and any suggestion that, when conditions change, active fund performance will significantly improve.

    BJ: When you see markets trending in one direction, the purest form of that market, be it a US total stock market index fund, or a US growth index fund is exceedingly difficult for active managers to outperform because those index funds by definition, are always fully invested and they are very style pure. So part of what we have been seeing is cyclical. Part of it is certainly structural if you just look at the elevation of the skillset, the game sort of the armaments of the active management industry. However, I think some of the other explanations, be it the low interest rate environment or quantitative easing, there is any number of frankly lame excuses that have been put forth by active managers.

    RP: Of course, no one knows when, or indeed whether, active managers will start performing better. The bottom line, though, is that active management is a zero-sum game. One manager has to win at another’s expense. Once you factor in fees and charges, you’re almost certainly better off indexing instead.

    Don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel where you'll find acres of digestible investor education - no matter what you're investing for.

    By subscribing, you can dip in and out and tailor your own learning programme.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel 

    Or get back to our Video Library to find more digestible content. 

    Getting better results, nothing less

    TALK TO US TODAY »